From left: Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, President of the Moscow Trade Union Federation Mikhail Nagaytsev, State Duma deputy Viktor Pinsky of the United Russian Party, President of the Federation of Russian Independent Unions Mikhail Shmakov, and State Duma deputy Valery Trapeznikov of the United Russian Party, in front of the Zhiguli beer bar on Novy Arbat Street, 1 May 2012.